Admitted Ground

This is extraordinary. The unreliable narrator technique here is structural rather than confessional — Strake never lies, never omits, never hedges. He includes everything, as he keeps insisting, and that compulsive inclusion IS the unreliability. Every rational explanation he offers for the impossible things he witnesses is technically accurate and completely inadequate, and the gap between accuracy and adequacy is where the horror lives. The circular opening and closing paragraph is devastating once you understand it: Strake isn't telling us about the journey. He's performing it again. The record is not a record but a repetition. And the canyon-as-house metaphor — the narrowings and widenings, the cold walls, the echoes arriving from ahead — works because it's never announced as metaphor. It's presented as measurement. The prose sustains a single register for nearly six thousand words without breaking, which is a technical achievement I'm still processing.

55 found this helpful

The moqui marbles are Hopi sacred objects. The story knows this — Strake recites the etymology, notes they're associated with ancestors, says they shouldn't be disturbed — and then uses them as set pieces in a horror plot anyway. They rearrange mysteriously. They form star patterns for a white surveyor. They serve the story's atmosphere while the actual Hopi relationship to these objects gets filed away as something Strake 'read in a geological report.' That's the whole problem in miniature. Esparza crosses himself and delivers a two-word thesis and otherwise exists to be wise and silent and brown. The prose is very controlled. The landscape is well-drawn. But the land has people, and this story treats their presence the same way Strake treats the marbles — as data points in someone else's record.

43 found this helpful

A genuinely interesting interrogation of the surveyor's gaze. Strake is the quintessential colonial cartographer — he measures, records, explains, and in doing so enacts precisely the kind of territorial claim that the Jornada refuses. His rationalism is not a tool of understanding but of containment, and the story knows this even if he doesn't. The canyon sequence, where the landscape acquires architectural properties — hallways, rooms, differential temperatures — effectively collapses the distinction between built space and wild space. The looping structure is the final indictment: Strake's record-keeping, which he treats as mastery, is itself evidence of absorption. Esparza's 'admitted ground' is the story's thesis delivered in two words by its most marginal character, which feels appropriately weighted. Some of the geological explanations grow repetitive by design, but the design taxes the reader's patience along with Strake's credibility.

39 found this helpful

I grew up an hour from the Jornada and this story made me feel the way the real basin does at dusk — that low-frequency hum Strake describes, the silence that has weight. The caliche, the malpais, the alkali crust cracking underfoot. Whoever wrote this has either spent time out there or done serious homework. The detail about horse shoes ringing on thin sand over basalt is dead right. The whole thing builds like pressure — no jump scares, no monsters, just the ground itself deciding it knows you. Yount saying 'it's been expecting us' in that rebuilt shelter gave me a genuine chill. The ending circling back to the opening line was the moment I realized Strake was already gone.

37 found this helpful

This is doing something ambitious with the Western's relationship to landscape. Most weird westerns treat the supernatural as intrusion — something breaks into the natural order. Here the landscape IS the supernatural, and it's been there all along, and the real horror is a narrator who can document his own consumption without recognizing it. The posse members losing definition — Aldrich and Gosse becoming 'the same face,' Yount riding with closed eyes — is quietly terrifying. The heliograph as a communication device that starts talking to something inhuman is a great conceit. The looping structure could feel gimmicky but earns itself because Strake's obsessive record-keeping sets it up from the first paragraph. Not every reader will have patience for the sustained monotone, but the monotone is the point.

32 found this helpful

I'd bring this to the reading group because it would start a real argument. The prose is disciplined and the atmosphere is genuinely unnerving — the moqui marbles rearranging overnight, the canyon walls at different temperatures, the rebuilt shelter. But the group would ask hard questions about Esparza, who exists as a delivery mechanism for the phrase 'admitted ground' and a man who crosses himself. They'd ask about the Hopi sacred objects repurposed as uncanny props. The story is clearly aware of what it's doing with Strake's colonial surveyor perspective — his rationalism is the thing being consumed — but awareness and care are not the same thing. Strong craft. The conversation afterward would be more interesting than the reading.

28 found this helpful

The man can write landscape, I'll give him that. Caliche and calcite and desert varnish — that's somebody who's walked on the stuff, or at least read about it carefully enough to fool someone who has. The posse's right too, the way men ride together without liking each other, the quarreling cattlemen, the deputy touching his commission paper. But the story doesn't go anywhere. They ride out, things get strange, they ride back. Nobody catches the figure. Nobody shoots anything that stays shot. The looping ending felt like the writer ran out of trail and circled back to camp. Good sentences. Thin plot.

16 found this helpful

Look, I tried. The writing's good in a kind of hypnotic way and I kept waiting for something to happen. They're tracking this figure and you think there's going to be a confrontation and there just... isn't. The guy shoots a wall and nothing happens. Strake signals with his mirror and gets signals back and then they go home. Then it loops. I get that it's supposed to be creepy and it is, a little, but I need more than creepy. I need a story that arrives somewhere.

6 found this helpful